How to make a person of color time traveller survive in the middle ages
up vote
8
down vote
favorite
The story centers around a group of people that get lost during in the woods and -for no apparent reason- suddenly find themselves in 13th century Europe (the Netherlands, to be precise). They don't know how they got there and there doesn't seem to be much they can do about it, so they stay in a small town for at least year till they figure out what has happened to them. In the meantime they try and make a living for themselves. Some of them find work, some use their skills and knowledge from the future to make a living.
One of them is a woman who has a dark skin.
My questions are:
How would people in the middle ages react to a dark-skinned person? There is no harbor in town and it's quite small, so chances are they've never seen someone with a dark skin. However, they might know of their existence because of the crusades: the story is placed at the start of the 13th century in the middle of the 5th crusade (not that the protagonists were involved, but a lot of dutch people participated in it so it must have been a thing at the time).
What would be a good occupation for my character? The original idea was to have her take on some medicinal activities, maybe even in disguise, but this was also at the time of witch burnings and such and I'm not sure how well people would've reacted to that.
Any recommendations for research literature are also welcome!
reality-check society medieval middle-ages
New contributor
add a comment |
up vote
8
down vote
favorite
The story centers around a group of people that get lost during in the woods and -for no apparent reason- suddenly find themselves in 13th century Europe (the Netherlands, to be precise). They don't know how they got there and there doesn't seem to be much they can do about it, so they stay in a small town for at least year till they figure out what has happened to them. In the meantime they try and make a living for themselves. Some of them find work, some use their skills and knowledge from the future to make a living.
One of them is a woman who has a dark skin.
My questions are:
How would people in the middle ages react to a dark-skinned person? There is no harbor in town and it's quite small, so chances are they've never seen someone with a dark skin. However, they might know of their existence because of the crusades: the story is placed at the start of the 13th century in the middle of the 5th crusade (not that the protagonists were involved, but a lot of dutch people participated in it so it must have been a thing at the time).
What would be a good occupation for my character? The original idea was to have her take on some medicinal activities, maybe even in disguise, but this was also at the time of witch burnings and such and I'm not sure how well people would've reacted to that.
Any recommendations for research literature are also welcome!
reality-check society medieval middle-ages
New contributor
2
Hi, I presume you have already checked out en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moors ? Apparently they could do quite well.
– pojo-guy
8 hours ago
Hi! Yes, the moors were more in the south of Europe though and I can't imagine a small city in the swamps of the low lands saw/knew a lot of them. I find it very difficult to imagine the world view of a normal villager at the time though; how someone who hadn't seen much more than the next village imagined the rest of the world to be
– canelaguila
7 hours ago
3
Why stay in a small town? Larger cities are pretty much always more friendly to strangers, and have more opportunities to work in a cash economy like your time travelers are presumably used to. And it's not like the Netherlands is especially hard to travel through.
– Cadence
7 hours ago
1
You might check out twitter.com/medievalpoc
– Russell Borogove
5 hours ago
This is an aside to the main question, however it's also worth for reality's sake to watch this little clip on 'how far back in time could you travel and still understand English?" youtube.com/watch?v=8fxy6ZaMOq8
– Aaron Lavers
3 hours ago
add a comment |
up vote
8
down vote
favorite
up vote
8
down vote
favorite
The story centers around a group of people that get lost during in the woods and -for no apparent reason- suddenly find themselves in 13th century Europe (the Netherlands, to be precise). They don't know how they got there and there doesn't seem to be much they can do about it, so they stay in a small town for at least year till they figure out what has happened to them. In the meantime they try and make a living for themselves. Some of them find work, some use their skills and knowledge from the future to make a living.
One of them is a woman who has a dark skin.
My questions are:
How would people in the middle ages react to a dark-skinned person? There is no harbor in town and it's quite small, so chances are they've never seen someone with a dark skin. However, they might know of their existence because of the crusades: the story is placed at the start of the 13th century in the middle of the 5th crusade (not that the protagonists were involved, but a lot of dutch people participated in it so it must have been a thing at the time).
What would be a good occupation for my character? The original idea was to have her take on some medicinal activities, maybe even in disguise, but this was also at the time of witch burnings and such and I'm not sure how well people would've reacted to that.
Any recommendations for research literature are also welcome!
reality-check society medieval middle-ages
New contributor
The story centers around a group of people that get lost during in the woods and -for no apparent reason- suddenly find themselves in 13th century Europe (the Netherlands, to be precise). They don't know how they got there and there doesn't seem to be much they can do about it, so they stay in a small town for at least year till they figure out what has happened to them. In the meantime they try and make a living for themselves. Some of them find work, some use their skills and knowledge from the future to make a living.
One of them is a woman who has a dark skin.
My questions are:
How would people in the middle ages react to a dark-skinned person? There is no harbor in town and it's quite small, so chances are they've never seen someone with a dark skin. However, they might know of their existence because of the crusades: the story is placed at the start of the 13th century in the middle of the 5th crusade (not that the protagonists were involved, but a lot of dutch people participated in it so it must have been a thing at the time).
What would be a good occupation for my character? The original idea was to have her take on some medicinal activities, maybe even in disguise, but this was also at the time of witch burnings and such and I'm not sure how well people would've reacted to that.
Any recommendations for research literature are also welcome!
reality-check society medieval middle-ages
reality-check society medieval middle-ages
New contributor
New contributor
edited 40 mins ago
Obie 2.0
1,182311
1,182311
New contributor
asked 8 hours ago
canelaguila
412
412
New contributor
New contributor
2
Hi, I presume you have already checked out en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moors ? Apparently they could do quite well.
– pojo-guy
8 hours ago
Hi! Yes, the moors were more in the south of Europe though and I can't imagine a small city in the swamps of the low lands saw/knew a lot of them. I find it very difficult to imagine the world view of a normal villager at the time though; how someone who hadn't seen much more than the next village imagined the rest of the world to be
– canelaguila
7 hours ago
3
Why stay in a small town? Larger cities are pretty much always more friendly to strangers, and have more opportunities to work in a cash economy like your time travelers are presumably used to. And it's not like the Netherlands is especially hard to travel through.
– Cadence
7 hours ago
1
You might check out twitter.com/medievalpoc
– Russell Borogove
5 hours ago
This is an aside to the main question, however it's also worth for reality's sake to watch this little clip on 'how far back in time could you travel and still understand English?" youtube.com/watch?v=8fxy6ZaMOq8
– Aaron Lavers
3 hours ago
add a comment |
2
Hi, I presume you have already checked out en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moors ? Apparently they could do quite well.
– pojo-guy
8 hours ago
Hi! Yes, the moors were more in the south of Europe though and I can't imagine a small city in the swamps of the low lands saw/knew a lot of them. I find it very difficult to imagine the world view of a normal villager at the time though; how someone who hadn't seen much more than the next village imagined the rest of the world to be
– canelaguila
7 hours ago
3
Why stay in a small town? Larger cities are pretty much always more friendly to strangers, and have more opportunities to work in a cash economy like your time travelers are presumably used to. And it's not like the Netherlands is especially hard to travel through.
– Cadence
7 hours ago
1
You might check out twitter.com/medievalpoc
– Russell Borogove
5 hours ago
This is an aside to the main question, however it's also worth for reality's sake to watch this little clip on 'how far back in time could you travel and still understand English?" youtube.com/watch?v=8fxy6ZaMOq8
– Aaron Lavers
3 hours ago
2
2
Hi, I presume you have already checked out en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moors ? Apparently they could do quite well.
– pojo-guy
8 hours ago
Hi, I presume you have already checked out en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moors ? Apparently they could do quite well.
– pojo-guy
8 hours ago
Hi! Yes, the moors were more in the south of Europe though and I can't imagine a small city in the swamps of the low lands saw/knew a lot of them. I find it very difficult to imagine the world view of a normal villager at the time though; how someone who hadn't seen much more than the next village imagined the rest of the world to be
– canelaguila
7 hours ago
Hi! Yes, the moors were more in the south of Europe though and I can't imagine a small city in the swamps of the low lands saw/knew a lot of them. I find it very difficult to imagine the world view of a normal villager at the time though; how someone who hadn't seen much more than the next village imagined the rest of the world to be
– canelaguila
7 hours ago
3
3
Why stay in a small town? Larger cities are pretty much always more friendly to strangers, and have more opportunities to work in a cash economy like your time travelers are presumably used to. And it's not like the Netherlands is especially hard to travel through.
– Cadence
7 hours ago
Why stay in a small town? Larger cities are pretty much always more friendly to strangers, and have more opportunities to work in a cash economy like your time travelers are presumably used to. And it's not like the Netherlands is especially hard to travel through.
– Cadence
7 hours ago
1
1
You might check out twitter.com/medievalpoc
– Russell Borogove
5 hours ago
You might check out twitter.com/medievalpoc
– Russell Borogove
5 hours ago
This is an aside to the main question, however it's also worth for reality's sake to watch this little clip on 'how far back in time could you travel and still understand English?" youtube.com/watch?v=8fxy6ZaMOq8
– Aaron Lavers
3 hours ago
This is an aside to the main question, however it's also worth for reality's sake to watch this little clip on 'how far back in time could you travel and still understand English?" youtube.com/watch?v=8fxy6ZaMOq8
– Aaron Lavers
3 hours ago
add a comment |
4 Answers
4
active
oldest
votes
up vote
11
down vote
She can be an Ethiopian Christian Pilgrim.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Council_of_Florence
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christianity_in_Ethiopia
In 1441 some Ethiopian monks travelled from Jerusalem to attend the
Council in Florence which discussed possible union between the Roman
Catholic and Greek Orthodox churches. The arrival of
the Christian monks caused something of a sensation. It began two
centuries of contact in which there were hopes to bring the Ethiopians
into the Catholic fold...
Would a small town in the Netherlands be aware that there might be a distant foreign Christian kingdom? Yes they would!
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prester_John
Prester John (Latin: Presbyter Johannes) was a legendary Christian
patriarch, presbyter (elder) and king who was popular in European
chronicles and tradition from the 12th through the 17th centuries. He
was said to rule over a Nestorian (Church of the East) Christian
nation lost amid the Muslims and pagans of the Orient, in which the
Patriarch of the Saint Thomas Christians resided.
Your traveler can say she is on a pilgrimage to visit some Christian site and get a blessing to take back to her ill husband. The people will be interested in her because of her exotic provenance but more comfortable because she is christian and also interested in the local holy site. She can make her living telling stories of distant lands and peoples. Probably no-one will pay her gold for stories, but they will put her up and feed her.
1
Good job on the Ethiopian Christian. The Ethiopian church traces it lineage to the einuch baptized by he the apostle Phillip in Acts 8, so the religious people of Europe would have a connection.
– pojo-guy
2 hours ago
add a comment |
up vote
3
down vote
The link to the Moors on Wikipedia is already provided in comments so I won't put it in here again, but it's important to note 2 things that are germane to your question;
1) The first 'Re-conquest' of the Moors in Spain occurred in the 13th Century
2) It was the sacking of the Moors that led to many of the developments in mathematics and science within the Christian worlds from that time through a couple of centuries because the Moors had been spending considerably more effort in enlightening themselves than the Christians of the time.
As an educated guess, your dark skinned time refugee would struggle socially, but the people of the Netherlands would express little concern or surprise at the technological or mathematical expertise of your traveler, assuming that she was a Moor. This would actually be a benefit to her because it's a convenient excuse as to why her language, customs, and occasional gaffes (like using Okay instead of All Right) may be forgiven.
To be blunt, in that era she's going to get more resistance from being a woman than she is being black but if she knows what she's doing she could easily set herself up in midwifery. That wouldn't be seen as that big a leap for women at the time, she'd already know more than the women of the day in many respects, and perhaps most importantly, if she saves mother and child from some awkward situations a couple of times over, all thoughts of witchcraft will probably go away on the grounds that there's no deodorant quite like success in this field.
Personally, I'd keep her away from technical or engineering fields - don't let her be a blacksmith or design buildings or do accounts for the local businesses. Their math was very different to modern mathematics for a start, and standing out in such fields, especially as a woman, is an ideal way to attract said unwanted attention of witch hunters.
Witch-hunt as popularly depicted, involving death penalty and burning started after the 13th century and peaked around the 16th-17th centuries
– Rafael
6 hours ago
your dark skinned time refugee would struggle socially Any time traveler would have this problem as they would have extreme difficulty even understanding old local speech (and idioms) as well as understanding social norms and attitudes and taboos. The dark skinned woman might even have an advantage in the sense she looks foreign and may (or may not) have more allowances made for her strange behavior and problems fitting in.
– StephenG
5 hours ago
"The first 'Re-conquest' of the Moors in Spain occurred in the 13th Century." Actually, it began centuries earlier and ended at the close of the 15th century. I'm genuinely curious as to what your definition of "first reconquest" is. Can you elaborate?
– Dan
2 hours ago
@Dan I took that directly from the wikipedia site above - there is a piece in the section on Iberian Moors that talks about the Moors being driven out in 1212 by Alphonso VIII. I agree with you about the general reconquest, and if I've misread the above I'll edit, but that is the source of the statement I've used above.
– Tim B II
2 hours ago
Ah, I see now. Yes, Granada held out for a couple of centuries between then and 1491, but generally, people refer to the reconquest as the entire period.
– Dan
2 hours ago
add a comment |
up vote
2
down vote
Be a leper.
Good excuse to cover up. Nobody will touch you and in fact will give you stuff to leave. If the woman has the assistance of the group, she should be able to survive without too much hassle
Another other option is a pilgrim. The group can speak for her and with extensive robes remain hidden.
Final option is to be blatant and open by being a travelling merchant from a far away land.
add a comment |
up vote
1
down vote
If it's only the woman who is dark skinned, the easiest solution is to pretend she's a war booty. One of her male colleagues will pretend he captured her in war in the south. If her actual boyfriend is part of the group that's even better. An independent woman if middle-ages was more suspicious than a dark skinned person. Most women had three choices - marriage, monastery or prostitution. Whether your character is actually married to her "captor" or just a concubine doesn't really matter.
As a bonus, being a captive from faraway lands she can explain some of her knowledge. People can be bit more forgiving of her exotic wisdom, as long as she's under control of her white man. Medicine is a good idea, but don't push it too far. Being a Moorish witch is not much better than local witch.
New contributor
add a comment |
Your Answer
StackExchange.ifUsing("editor", function () {
return StackExchange.using("mathjaxEditing", function () {
StackExchange.MarkdownEditor.creationCallbacks.add(function (editor, postfix) {
StackExchange.mathjaxEditing.prepareWmdForMathJax(editor, postfix, [["$", "$"], ["\\(","\\)"]]);
});
});
}, "mathjax-editing");
StackExchange.ready(function() {
var channelOptions = {
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "579"
};
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);
StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
createEditor();
});
}
else {
createEditor();
}
});
function createEditor() {
StackExchange.prepareEditor({
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: false,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: null,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader: {
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
},
noCode: true, onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
});
}
});
canelaguila is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fworldbuilding.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f134350%2fhow-to-make-a-person-of-color-time-traveller-survive-in-the-middle-ages%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
4 Answers
4
active
oldest
votes
4 Answers
4
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
up vote
11
down vote
She can be an Ethiopian Christian Pilgrim.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Council_of_Florence
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christianity_in_Ethiopia
In 1441 some Ethiopian monks travelled from Jerusalem to attend the
Council in Florence which discussed possible union between the Roman
Catholic and Greek Orthodox churches. The arrival of
the Christian monks caused something of a sensation. It began two
centuries of contact in which there were hopes to bring the Ethiopians
into the Catholic fold...
Would a small town in the Netherlands be aware that there might be a distant foreign Christian kingdom? Yes they would!
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prester_John
Prester John (Latin: Presbyter Johannes) was a legendary Christian
patriarch, presbyter (elder) and king who was popular in European
chronicles and tradition from the 12th through the 17th centuries. He
was said to rule over a Nestorian (Church of the East) Christian
nation lost amid the Muslims and pagans of the Orient, in which the
Patriarch of the Saint Thomas Christians resided.
Your traveler can say she is on a pilgrimage to visit some Christian site and get a blessing to take back to her ill husband. The people will be interested in her because of her exotic provenance but more comfortable because she is christian and also interested in the local holy site. She can make her living telling stories of distant lands and peoples. Probably no-one will pay her gold for stories, but they will put her up and feed her.
1
Good job on the Ethiopian Christian. The Ethiopian church traces it lineage to the einuch baptized by he the apostle Phillip in Acts 8, so the religious people of Europe would have a connection.
– pojo-guy
2 hours ago
add a comment |
up vote
11
down vote
She can be an Ethiopian Christian Pilgrim.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Council_of_Florence
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christianity_in_Ethiopia
In 1441 some Ethiopian monks travelled from Jerusalem to attend the
Council in Florence which discussed possible union between the Roman
Catholic and Greek Orthodox churches. The arrival of
the Christian monks caused something of a sensation. It began two
centuries of contact in which there were hopes to bring the Ethiopians
into the Catholic fold...
Would a small town in the Netherlands be aware that there might be a distant foreign Christian kingdom? Yes they would!
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prester_John
Prester John (Latin: Presbyter Johannes) was a legendary Christian
patriarch, presbyter (elder) and king who was popular in European
chronicles and tradition from the 12th through the 17th centuries. He
was said to rule over a Nestorian (Church of the East) Christian
nation lost amid the Muslims and pagans of the Orient, in which the
Patriarch of the Saint Thomas Christians resided.
Your traveler can say she is on a pilgrimage to visit some Christian site and get a blessing to take back to her ill husband. The people will be interested in her because of her exotic provenance but more comfortable because she is christian and also interested in the local holy site. She can make her living telling stories of distant lands and peoples. Probably no-one will pay her gold for stories, but they will put her up and feed her.
1
Good job on the Ethiopian Christian. The Ethiopian church traces it lineage to the einuch baptized by he the apostle Phillip in Acts 8, so the religious people of Europe would have a connection.
– pojo-guy
2 hours ago
add a comment |
up vote
11
down vote
up vote
11
down vote
She can be an Ethiopian Christian Pilgrim.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Council_of_Florence
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christianity_in_Ethiopia
In 1441 some Ethiopian monks travelled from Jerusalem to attend the
Council in Florence which discussed possible union between the Roman
Catholic and Greek Orthodox churches. The arrival of
the Christian monks caused something of a sensation. It began two
centuries of contact in which there were hopes to bring the Ethiopians
into the Catholic fold...
Would a small town in the Netherlands be aware that there might be a distant foreign Christian kingdom? Yes they would!
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prester_John
Prester John (Latin: Presbyter Johannes) was a legendary Christian
patriarch, presbyter (elder) and king who was popular in European
chronicles and tradition from the 12th through the 17th centuries. He
was said to rule over a Nestorian (Church of the East) Christian
nation lost amid the Muslims and pagans of the Orient, in which the
Patriarch of the Saint Thomas Christians resided.
Your traveler can say she is on a pilgrimage to visit some Christian site and get a blessing to take back to her ill husband. The people will be interested in her because of her exotic provenance but more comfortable because she is christian and also interested in the local holy site. She can make her living telling stories of distant lands and peoples. Probably no-one will pay her gold for stories, but they will put her up and feed her.
She can be an Ethiopian Christian Pilgrim.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Council_of_Florence
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christianity_in_Ethiopia
In 1441 some Ethiopian monks travelled from Jerusalem to attend the
Council in Florence which discussed possible union between the Roman
Catholic and Greek Orthodox churches. The arrival of
the Christian monks caused something of a sensation. It began two
centuries of contact in which there were hopes to bring the Ethiopians
into the Catholic fold...
Would a small town in the Netherlands be aware that there might be a distant foreign Christian kingdom? Yes they would!
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prester_John
Prester John (Latin: Presbyter Johannes) was a legendary Christian
patriarch, presbyter (elder) and king who was popular in European
chronicles and tradition from the 12th through the 17th centuries. He
was said to rule over a Nestorian (Church of the East) Christian
nation lost amid the Muslims and pagans of the Orient, in which the
Patriarch of the Saint Thomas Christians resided.
Your traveler can say she is on a pilgrimage to visit some Christian site and get a blessing to take back to her ill husband. The people will be interested in her because of her exotic provenance but more comfortable because she is christian and also interested in the local holy site. She can make her living telling stories of distant lands and peoples. Probably no-one will pay her gold for stories, but they will put her up and feed her.
edited 6 hours ago
answered 6 hours ago
Willk
99.3k25190418
99.3k25190418
1
Good job on the Ethiopian Christian. The Ethiopian church traces it lineage to the einuch baptized by he the apostle Phillip in Acts 8, so the religious people of Europe would have a connection.
– pojo-guy
2 hours ago
add a comment |
1
Good job on the Ethiopian Christian. The Ethiopian church traces it lineage to the einuch baptized by he the apostle Phillip in Acts 8, so the religious people of Europe would have a connection.
– pojo-guy
2 hours ago
1
1
Good job on the Ethiopian Christian. The Ethiopian church traces it lineage to the einuch baptized by he the apostle Phillip in Acts 8, so the religious people of Europe would have a connection.
– pojo-guy
2 hours ago
Good job on the Ethiopian Christian. The Ethiopian church traces it lineage to the einuch baptized by he the apostle Phillip in Acts 8, so the religious people of Europe would have a connection.
– pojo-guy
2 hours ago
add a comment |
up vote
3
down vote
The link to the Moors on Wikipedia is already provided in comments so I won't put it in here again, but it's important to note 2 things that are germane to your question;
1) The first 'Re-conquest' of the Moors in Spain occurred in the 13th Century
2) It was the sacking of the Moors that led to many of the developments in mathematics and science within the Christian worlds from that time through a couple of centuries because the Moors had been spending considerably more effort in enlightening themselves than the Christians of the time.
As an educated guess, your dark skinned time refugee would struggle socially, but the people of the Netherlands would express little concern or surprise at the technological or mathematical expertise of your traveler, assuming that she was a Moor. This would actually be a benefit to her because it's a convenient excuse as to why her language, customs, and occasional gaffes (like using Okay instead of All Right) may be forgiven.
To be blunt, in that era she's going to get more resistance from being a woman than she is being black but if she knows what she's doing she could easily set herself up in midwifery. That wouldn't be seen as that big a leap for women at the time, she'd already know more than the women of the day in many respects, and perhaps most importantly, if she saves mother and child from some awkward situations a couple of times over, all thoughts of witchcraft will probably go away on the grounds that there's no deodorant quite like success in this field.
Personally, I'd keep her away from technical or engineering fields - don't let her be a blacksmith or design buildings or do accounts for the local businesses. Their math was very different to modern mathematics for a start, and standing out in such fields, especially as a woman, is an ideal way to attract said unwanted attention of witch hunters.
Witch-hunt as popularly depicted, involving death penalty and burning started after the 13th century and peaked around the 16th-17th centuries
– Rafael
6 hours ago
your dark skinned time refugee would struggle socially Any time traveler would have this problem as they would have extreme difficulty even understanding old local speech (and idioms) as well as understanding social norms and attitudes and taboos. The dark skinned woman might even have an advantage in the sense she looks foreign and may (or may not) have more allowances made for her strange behavior and problems fitting in.
– StephenG
5 hours ago
"The first 'Re-conquest' of the Moors in Spain occurred in the 13th Century." Actually, it began centuries earlier and ended at the close of the 15th century. I'm genuinely curious as to what your definition of "first reconquest" is. Can you elaborate?
– Dan
2 hours ago
@Dan I took that directly from the wikipedia site above - there is a piece in the section on Iberian Moors that talks about the Moors being driven out in 1212 by Alphonso VIII. I agree with you about the general reconquest, and if I've misread the above I'll edit, but that is the source of the statement I've used above.
– Tim B II
2 hours ago
Ah, I see now. Yes, Granada held out for a couple of centuries between then and 1491, but generally, people refer to the reconquest as the entire period.
– Dan
2 hours ago
add a comment |
up vote
3
down vote
The link to the Moors on Wikipedia is already provided in comments so I won't put it in here again, but it's important to note 2 things that are germane to your question;
1) The first 'Re-conquest' of the Moors in Spain occurred in the 13th Century
2) It was the sacking of the Moors that led to many of the developments in mathematics and science within the Christian worlds from that time through a couple of centuries because the Moors had been spending considerably more effort in enlightening themselves than the Christians of the time.
As an educated guess, your dark skinned time refugee would struggle socially, but the people of the Netherlands would express little concern or surprise at the technological or mathematical expertise of your traveler, assuming that she was a Moor. This would actually be a benefit to her because it's a convenient excuse as to why her language, customs, and occasional gaffes (like using Okay instead of All Right) may be forgiven.
To be blunt, in that era she's going to get more resistance from being a woman than she is being black but if she knows what she's doing she could easily set herself up in midwifery. That wouldn't be seen as that big a leap for women at the time, she'd already know more than the women of the day in many respects, and perhaps most importantly, if she saves mother and child from some awkward situations a couple of times over, all thoughts of witchcraft will probably go away on the grounds that there's no deodorant quite like success in this field.
Personally, I'd keep her away from technical or engineering fields - don't let her be a blacksmith or design buildings or do accounts for the local businesses. Their math was very different to modern mathematics for a start, and standing out in such fields, especially as a woman, is an ideal way to attract said unwanted attention of witch hunters.
Witch-hunt as popularly depicted, involving death penalty and burning started after the 13th century and peaked around the 16th-17th centuries
– Rafael
6 hours ago
your dark skinned time refugee would struggle socially Any time traveler would have this problem as they would have extreme difficulty even understanding old local speech (and idioms) as well as understanding social norms and attitudes and taboos. The dark skinned woman might even have an advantage in the sense she looks foreign and may (or may not) have more allowances made for her strange behavior and problems fitting in.
– StephenG
5 hours ago
"The first 'Re-conquest' of the Moors in Spain occurred in the 13th Century." Actually, it began centuries earlier and ended at the close of the 15th century. I'm genuinely curious as to what your definition of "first reconquest" is. Can you elaborate?
– Dan
2 hours ago
@Dan I took that directly from the wikipedia site above - there is a piece in the section on Iberian Moors that talks about the Moors being driven out in 1212 by Alphonso VIII. I agree with you about the general reconquest, and if I've misread the above I'll edit, but that is the source of the statement I've used above.
– Tim B II
2 hours ago
Ah, I see now. Yes, Granada held out for a couple of centuries between then and 1491, but generally, people refer to the reconquest as the entire period.
– Dan
2 hours ago
add a comment |
up vote
3
down vote
up vote
3
down vote
The link to the Moors on Wikipedia is already provided in comments so I won't put it in here again, but it's important to note 2 things that are germane to your question;
1) The first 'Re-conquest' of the Moors in Spain occurred in the 13th Century
2) It was the sacking of the Moors that led to many of the developments in mathematics and science within the Christian worlds from that time through a couple of centuries because the Moors had been spending considerably more effort in enlightening themselves than the Christians of the time.
As an educated guess, your dark skinned time refugee would struggle socially, but the people of the Netherlands would express little concern or surprise at the technological or mathematical expertise of your traveler, assuming that she was a Moor. This would actually be a benefit to her because it's a convenient excuse as to why her language, customs, and occasional gaffes (like using Okay instead of All Right) may be forgiven.
To be blunt, in that era she's going to get more resistance from being a woman than she is being black but if she knows what she's doing she could easily set herself up in midwifery. That wouldn't be seen as that big a leap for women at the time, she'd already know more than the women of the day in many respects, and perhaps most importantly, if she saves mother and child from some awkward situations a couple of times over, all thoughts of witchcraft will probably go away on the grounds that there's no deodorant quite like success in this field.
Personally, I'd keep her away from technical or engineering fields - don't let her be a blacksmith or design buildings or do accounts for the local businesses. Their math was very different to modern mathematics for a start, and standing out in such fields, especially as a woman, is an ideal way to attract said unwanted attention of witch hunters.
The link to the Moors on Wikipedia is already provided in comments so I won't put it in here again, but it's important to note 2 things that are germane to your question;
1) The first 'Re-conquest' of the Moors in Spain occurred in the 13th Century
2) It was the sacking of the Moors that led to many of the developments in mathematics and science within the Christian worlds from that time through a couple of centuries because the Moors had been spending considerably more effort in enlightening themselves than the Christians of the time.
As an educated guess, your dark skinned time refugee would struggle socially, but the people of the Netherlands would express little concern or surprise at the technological or mathematical expertise of your traveler, assuming that she was a Moor. This would actually be a benefit to her because it's a convenient excuse as to why her language, customs, and occasional gaffes (like using Okay instead of All Right) may be forgiven.
To be blunt, in that era she's going to get more resistance from being a woman than she is being black but if she knows what she's doing she could easily set herself up in midwifery. That wouldn't be seen as that big a leap for women at the time, she'd already know more than the women of the day in many respects, and perhaps most importantly, if she saves mother and child from some awkward situations a couple of times over, all thoughts of witchcraft will probably go away on the grounds that there's no deodorant quite like success in this field.
Personally, I'd keep her away from technical or engineering fields - don't let her be a blacksmith or design buildings or do accounts for the local businesses. Their math was very different to modern mathematics for a start, and standing out in such fields, especially as a woman, is an ideal way to attract said unwanted attention of witch hunters.
answered 7 hours ago
Tim B II
24.4k653104
24.4k653104
Witch-hunt as popularly depicted, involving death penalty and burning started after the 13th century and peaked around the 16th-17th centuries
– Rafael
6 hours ago
your dark skinned time refugee would struggle socially Any time traveler would have this problem as they would have extreme difficulty even understanding old local speech (and idioms) as well as understanding social norms and attitudes and taboos. The dark skinned woman might even have an advantage in the sense she looks foreign and may (or may not) have more allowances made for her strange behavior and problems fitting in.
– StephenG
5 hours ago
"The first 'Re-conquest' of the Moors in Spain occurred in the 13th Century." Actually, it began centuries earlier and ended at the close of the 15th century. I'm genuinely curious as to what your definition of "first reconquest" is. Can you elaborate?
– Dan
2 hours ago
@Dan I took that directly from the wikipedia site above - there is a piece in the section on Iberian Moors that talks about the Moors being driven out in 1212 by Alphonso VIII. I agree with you about the general reconquest, and if I've misread the above I'll edit, but that is the source of the statement I've used above.
– Tim B II
2 hours ago
Ah, I see now. Yes, Granada held out for a couple of centuries between then and 1491, but generally, people refer to the reconquest as the entire period.
– Dan
2 hours ago
add a comment |
Witch-hunt as popularly depicted, involving death penalty and burning started after the 13th century and peaked around the 16th-17th centuries
– Rafael
6 hours ago
your dark skinned time refugee would struggle socially Any time traveler would have this problem as they would have extreme difficulty even understanding old local speech (and idioms) as well as understanding social norms and attitudes and taboos. The dark skinned woman might even have an advantage in the sense she looks foreign and may (or may not) have more allowances made for her strange behavior and problems fitting in.
– StephenG
5 hours ago
"The first 'Re-conquest' of the Moors in Spain occurred in the 13th Century." Actually, it began centuries earlier and ended at the close of the 15th century. I'm genuinely curious as to what your definition of "first reconquest" is. Can you elaborate?
– Dan
2 hours ago
@Dan I took that directly from the wikipedia site above - there is a piece in the section on Iberian Moors that talks about the Moors being driven out in 1212 by Alphonso VIII. I agree with you about the general reconquest, and if I've misread the above I'll edit, but that is the source of the statement I've used above.
– Tim B II
2 hours ago
Ah, I see now. Yes, Granada held out for a couple of centuries between then and 1491, but generally, people refer to the reconquest as the entire period.
– Dan
2 hours ago
Witch-hunt as popularly depicted, involving death penalty and burning started after the 13th century and peaked around the 16th-17th centuries
– Rafael
6 hours ago
Witch-hunt as popularly depicted, involving death penalty and burning started after the 13th century and peaked around the 16th-17th centuries
– Rafael
6 hours ago
your dark skinned time refugee would struggle socially Any time traveler would have this problem as they would have extreme difficulty even understanding old local speech (and idioms) as well as understanding social norms and attitudes and taboos. The dark skinned woman might even have an advantage in the sense she looks foreign and may (or may not) have more allowances made for her strange behavior and problems fitting in.
– StephenG
5 hours ago
your dark skinned time refugee would struggle socially Any time traveler would have this problem as they would have extreme difficulty even understanding old local speech (and idioms) as well as understanding social norms and attitudes and taboos. The dark skinned woman might even have an advantage in the sense she looks foreign and may (or may not) have more allowances made for her strange behavior and problems fitting in.
– StephenG
5 hours ago
"The first 'Re-conquest' of the Moors in Spain occurred in the 13th Century." Actually, it began centuries earlier and ended at the close of the 15th century. I'm genuinely curious as to what your definition of "first reconquest" is. Can you elaborate?
– Dan
2 hours ago
"The first 'Re-conquest' of the Moors in Spain occurred in the 13th Century." Actually, it began centuries earlier and ended at the close of the 15th century. I'm genuinely curious as to what your definition of "first reconquest" is. Can you elaborate?
– Dan
2 hours ago
@Dan I took that directly from the wikipedia site above - there is a piece in the section on Iberian Moors that talks about the Moors being driven out in 1212 by Alphonso VIII. I agree with you about the general reconquest, and if I've misread the above I'll edit, but that is the source of the statement I've used above.
– Tim B II
2 hours ago
@Dan I took that directly from the wikipedia site above - there is a piece in the section on Iberian Moors that talks about the Moors being driven out in 1212 by Alphonso VIII. I agree with you about the general reconquest, and if I've misread the above I'll edit, but that is the source of the statement I've used above.
– Tim B II
2 hours ago
Ah, I see now. Yes, Granada held out for a couple of centuries between then and 1491, but generally, people refer to the reconquest as the entire period.
– Dan
2 hours ago
Ah, I see now. Yes, Granada held out for a couple of centuries between then and 1491, but generally, people refer to the reconquest as the entire period.
– Dan
2 hours ago
add a comment |
up vote
2
down vote
Be a leper.
Good excuse to cover up. Nobody will touch you and in fact will give you stuff to leave. If the woman has the assistance of the group, she should be able to survive without too much hassle
Another other option is a pilgrim. The group can speak for her and with extensive robes remain hidden.
Final option is to be blatant and open by being a travelling merchant from a far away land.
add a comment |
up vote
2
down vote
Be a leper.
Good excuse to cover up. Nobody will touch you and in fact will give you stuff to leave. If the woman has the assistance of the group, she should be able to survive without too much hassle
Another other option is a pilgrim. The group can speak for her and with extensive robes remain hidden.
Final option is to be blatant and open by being a travelling merchant from a far away land.
add a comment |
up vote
2
down vote
up vote
2
down vote
Be a leper.
Good excuse to cover up. Nobody will touch you and in fact will give you stuff to leave. If the woman has the assistance of the group, she should be able to survive without too much hassle
Another other option is a pilgrim. The group can speak for her and with extensive robes remain hidden.
Final option is to be blatant and open by being a travelling merchant from a far away land.
Be a leper.
Good excuse to cover up. Nobody will touch you and in fact will give you stuff to leave. If the woman has the assistance of the group, she should be able to survive without too much hassle
Another other option is a pilgrim. The group can speak for her and with extensive robes remain hidden.
Final option is to be blatant and open by being a travelling merchant from a far away land.
answered 6 hours ago
Thorne
14k42040
14k42040
add a comment |
add a comment |
up vote
1
down vote
If it's only the woman who is dark skinned, the easiest solution is to pretend she's a war booty. One of her male colleagues will pretend he captured her in war in the south. If her actual boyfriend is part of the group that's even better. An independent woman if middle-ages was more suspicious than a dark skinned person. Most women had three choices - marriage, monastery or prostitution. Whether your character is actually married to her "captor" or just a concubine doesn't really matter.
As a bonus, being a captive from faraway lands she can explain some of her knowledge. People can be bit more forgiving of her exotic wisdom, as long as she's under control of her white man. Medicine is a good idea, but don't push it too far. Being a Moorish witch is not much better than local witch.
New contributor
add a comment |
up vote
1
down vote
If it's only the woman who is dark skinned, the easiest solution is to pretend she's a war booty. One of her male colleagues will pretend he captured her in war in the south. If her actual boyfriend is part of the group that's even better. An independent woman if middle-ages was more suspicious than a dark skinned person. Most women had three choices - marriage, monastery or prostitution. Whether your character is actually married to her "captor" or just a concubine doesn't really matter.
As a bonus, being a captive from faraway lands she can explain some of her knowledge. People can be bit more forgiving of her exotic wisdom, as long as she's under control of her white man. Medicine is a good idea, but don't push it too far. Being a Moorish witch is not much better than local witch.
New contributor
add a comment |
up vote
1
down vote
up vote
1
down vote
If it's only the woman who is dark skinned, the easiest solution is to pretend she's a war booty. One of her male colleagues will pretend he captured her in war in the south. If her actual boyfriend is part of the group that's even better. An independent woman if middle-ages was more suspicious than a dark skinned person. Most women had three choices - marriage, monastery or prostitution. Whether your character is actually married to her "captor" or just a concubine doesn't really matter.
As a bonus, being a captive from faraway lands she can explain some of her knowledge. People can be bit more forgiving of her exotic wisdom, as long as she's under control of her white man. Medicine is a good idea, but don't push it too far. Being a Moorish witch is not much better than local witch.
New contributor
If it's only the woman who is dark skinned, the easiest solution is to pretend she's a war booty. One of her male colleagues will pretend he captured her in war in the south. If her actual boyfriend is part of the group that's even better. An independent woman if middle-ages was more suspicious than a dark skinned person. Most women had three choices - marriage, monastery or prostitution. Whether your character is actually married to her "captor" or just a concubine doesn't really matter.
As a bonus, being a captive from faraway lands she can explain some of her knowledge. People can be bit more forgiving of her exotic wisdom, as long as she's under control of her white man. Medicine is a good idea, but don't push it too far. Being a Moorish witch is not much better than local witch.
New contributor
New contributor
answered 6 hours ago
Maiki Bodhisattva
273
273
New contributor
New contributor
add a comment |
add a comment |
canelaguila is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
canelaguila is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
canelaguila is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
canelaguila is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
Thanks for contributing an answer to Worldbuilding Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
Use MathJax to format equations. MathJax reference.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Some of your past answers have not been well-received, and you're in danger of being blocked from answering.
Please pay close attention to the following guidance:
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fworldbuilding.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f134350%2fhow-to-make-a-person-of-color-time-traveller-survive-in-the-middle-ages%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
2
Hi, I presume you have already checked out en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moors ? Apparently they could do quite well.
– pojo-guy
8 hours ago
Hi! Yes, the moors were more in the south of Europe though and I can't imagine a small city in the swamps of the low lands saw/knew a lot of them. I find it very difficult to imagine the world view of a normal villager at the time though; how someone who hadn't seen much more than the next village imagined the rest of the world to be
– canelaguila
7 hours ago
3
Why stay in a small town? Larger cities are pretty much always more friendly to strangers, and have more opportunities to work in a cash economy like your time travelers are presumably used to. And it's not like the Netherlands is especially hard to travel through.
– Cadence
7 hours ago
1
You might check out twitter.com/medievalpoc
– Russell Borogove
5 hours ago
This is an aside to the main question, however it's also worth for reality's sake to watch this little clip on 'how far back in time could you travel and still understand English?" youtube.com/watch?v=8fxy6ZaMOq8
– Aaron Lavers
3 hours ago