Why is wombat excreta shaped like cubes?
up vote
19
down vote
favorite
I've heard that wombat excreta is cube shaped, but I don't understand how that can happen. Has anyone studied the phenomenon? What would the evolutionary pressure have been to cause this?
zoology physiology ethology mammals digestion
add a comment |
up vote
19
down vote
favorite
I've heard that wombat excreta is cube shaped, but I don't understand how that can happen. Has anyone studied the phenomenon? What would the evolutionary pressure have been to cause this?
zoology physiology ethology mammals digestion
add a comment |
up vote
19
down vote
favorite
up vote
19
down vote
favorite
I've heard that wombat excreta is cube shaped, but I don't understand how that can happen. Has anyone studied the phenomenon? What would the evolutionary pressure have been to cause this?
zoology physiology ethology mammals digestion
I've heard that wombat excreta is cube shaped, but I don't understand how that can happen. Has anyone studied the phenomenon? What would the evolutionary pressure have been to cause this?
zoology physiology ethology mammals digestion
zoology physiology ethology mammals digestion
edited Nov 19 at 23:08
David
11.5k41747
11.5k41747
asked Nov 19 at 22:19
ASimonis
35119
35119
add a comment |
add a comment |
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
up vote
23
down vote
I'm almost certain that your question is based on the press that Patricia J Yang's research is receiving (e.g., here and here).
Yang and her co-authors examined the structure and mechanics of some dead wombats to investigate this question further. They found that varying degrees of pressure in the latter portion of the wombat's intestines (in conjunction with a dehydrating of the fecal matter) led to the characteristic cube shape:
From their abstract:
In the final 8 percent of the intestine, feces changed from a liquid-like state into a solid state composed of separated cubes of length 2 cm. This shape change was due to the azimuthally varying elastic properties of the intestinal wall. By emptying the intestine and inflating it with a long balloon, we found that the local strain varies from 20 percent at the cube's corners to 75 percent at its edges. Thus, the intestine stretches preferentially at the walls to facilitate cube formation.
Why do this?
There seems to be two major reasons:
- Mark territory
- Attract mates
For example, see Wells 19891:
The rubbing of posts, logs and overhanging branches with their backs and rumps and deposition of faeces along trails may be a means of olfactory communication used in the maintenance of territories
One hypothesis is that by being square, the droppings don't roll as easily and therefore stay in the place that the wombat intended to mark.
I've also seen hypotheses about wombats stacking their square feces as some sort of signaling, but I couldn't find any reputable literature sources that make this suggestion.
1: Wells, R.T., 1989. Vombatidae. Fauna of Australia, 1, pp.755-768.
1
The "Why do this?" part doesn't really explain why. Plenty of other creatures mark territory and attract mates, and they don't have square poops. Similarly the Wells quote seems unrelated.
– Parrotmaster
Nov 20 at 14:51
5
@Parrotmaster: As nature continually proves, multiple solutions to the same problem exist. Plenty of creatures are land-based animals but that doesn't prove that birds shouldn't have evolved to have wings. Recognizability of feces may not have been the reason for its inception (random mutations tend to be the reason for the inception of a trait), but the subsequent benefit of recognizability of the uniquely shaped droppings may explain why the trait persisted.
– Flater
Nov 20 at 15:09
1
@Parrotmaster take a look at Wells's paper for number of citations regarding the ethology and social-ecology of wombats
– theforestecologist
Nov 20 at 15:30
1
probably means there are 4 muscles around the intestine that form a square.
– gunfulker
Nov 20 at 20:37
1
@GraphTheory, no. The intestine supposedly just squeezes differentially due to varying elastic properties of the intestinal wall.
– theforestecologist
Nov 20 at 21:41
|
show 2 more comments
up vote
9
down vote
On a more serious note than my comment, and as a supplement to theforestecologist's answer, it's worth pointing out that a cube with rounded corners and edges has larger surface area to volume ratio than a spherical dropping, making it more efficient for the reabsorbtion of moisture, which would be an evolutionary advantage in a place where water is in short supply (as it is in large parts of Australia).
Additionally, in respect of the claim made here that droppings are used for marking, it may be advantageous to have a dropping that doesn't roll, if it's important some subsequent visitor can identify the precise spot the droppings were dropped, especially if one inhabits sloped terrain (which a wombat does - mountainous areas of Australia) where a round dropping might roll and mark an ambiguous spot.
Some of the information contained in this post requires additional references. Please edit to add citations to reliable sources that support the assertions made here. Unsourced material may be disputed or deleted.
2
Why would feces reabsorbing moisture be an advantage? Do wombats eat their droppings?
– Paul
Nov 20 at 12:44
7
@Paul I guess he meant colon absorbing moisture from feces to conserve water.
– user31389
Nov 20 at 13:00
9
@Paul a standard function of the colon in all animals is to reabsorb nutrients and fluid from doo doo before it's expelled.
– Robert Frost
Nov 20 at 13:29
add a comment |
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
up vote
23
down vote
I'm almost certain that your question is based on the press that Patricia J Yang's research is receiving (e.g., here and here).
Yang and her co-authors examined the structure and mechanics of some dead wombats to investigate this question further. They found that varying degrees of pressure in the latter portion of the wombat's intestines (in conjunction with a dehydrating of the fecal matter) led to the characteristic cube shape:
From their abstract:
In the final 8 percent of the intestine, feces changed from a liquid-like state into a solid state composed of separated cubes of length 2 cm. This shape change was due to the azimuthally varying elastic properties of the intestinal wall. By emptying the intestine and inflating it with a long balloon, we found that the local strain varies from 20 percent at the cube's corners to 75 percent at its edges. Thus, the intestine stretches preferentially at the walls to facilitate cube formation.
Why do this?
There seems to be two major reasons:
- Mark territory
- Attract mates
For example, see Wells 19891:
The rubbing of posts, logs and overhanging branches with their backs and rumps and deposition of faeces along trails may be a means of olfactory communication used in the maintenance of territories
One hypothesis is that by being square, the droppings don't roll as easily and therefore stay in the place that the wombat intended to mark.
I've also seen hypotheses about wombats stacking their square feces as some sort of signaling, but I couldn't find any reputable literature sources that make this suggestion.
1: Wells, R.T., 1989. Vombatidae. Fauna of Australia, 1, pp.755-768.
1
The "Why do this?" part doesn't really explain why. Plenty of other creatures mark territory and attract mates, and they don't have square poops. Similarly the Wells quote seems unrelated.
– Parrotmaster
Nov 20 at 14:51
5
@Parrotmaster: As nature continually proves, multiple solutions to the same problem exist. Plenty of creatures are land-based animals but that doesn't prove that birds shouldn't have evolved to have wings. Recognizability of feces may not have been the reason for its inception (random mutations tend to be the reason for the inception of a trait), but the subsequent benefit of recognizability of the uniquely shaped droppings may explain why the trait persisted.
– Flater
Nov 20 at 15:09
1
@Parrotmaster take a look at Wells's paper for number of citations regarding the ethology and social-ecology of wombats
– theforestecologist
Nov 20 at 15:30
1
probably means there are 4 muscles around the intestine that form a square.
– gunfulker
Nov 20 at 20:37
1
@GraphTheory, no. The intestine supposedly just squeezes differentially due to varying elastic properties of the intestinal wall.
– theforestecologist
Nov 20 at 21:41
|
show 2 more comments
up vote
23
down vote
I'm almost certain that your question is based on the press that Patricia J Yang's research is receiving (e.g., here and here).
Yang and her co-authors examined the structure and mechanics of some dead wombats to investigate this question further. They found that varying degrees of pressure in the latter portion of the wombat's intestines (in conjunction with a dehydrating of the fecal matter) led to the characteristic cube shape:
From their abstract:
In the final 8 percent of the intestine, feces changed from a liquid-like state into a solid state composed of separated cubes of length 2 cm. This shape change was due to the azimuthally varying elastic properties of the intestinal wall. By emptying the intestine and inflating it with a long balloon, we found that the local strain varies from 20 percent at the cube's corners to 75 percent at its edges. Thus, the intestine stretches preferentially at the walls to facilitate cube formation.
Why do this?
There seems to be two major reasons:
- Mark territory
- Attract mates
For example, see Wells 19891:
The rubbing of posts, logs and overhanging branches with their backs and rumps and deposition of faeces along trails may be a means of olfactory communication used in the maintenance of territories
One hypothesis is that by being square, the droppings don't roll as easily and therefore stay in the place that the wombat intended to mark.
I've also seen hypotheses about wombats stacking their square feces as some sort of signaling, but I couldn't find any reputable literature sources that make this suggestion.
1: Wells, R.T., 1989. Vombatidae. Fauna of Australia, 1, pp.755-768.
1
The "Why do this?" part doesn't really explain why. Plenty of other creatures mark territory and attract mates, and they don't have square poops. Similarly the Wells quote seems unrelated.
– Parrotmaster
Nov 20 at 14:51
5
@Parrotmaster: As nature continually proves, multiple solutions to the same problem exist. Plenty of creatures are land-based animals but that doesn't prove that birds shouldn't have evolved to have wings. Recognizability of feces may not have been the reason for its inception (random mutations tend to be the reason for the inception of a trait), but the subsequent benefit of recognizability of the uniquely shaped droppings may explain why the trait persisted.
– Flater
Nov 20 at 15:09
1
@Parrotmaster take a look at Wells's paper for number of citations regarding the ethology and social-ecology of wombats
– theforestecologist
Nov 20 at 15:30
1
probably means there are 4 muscles around the intestine that form a square.
– gunfulker
Nov 20 at 20:37
1
@GraphTheory, no. The intestine supposedly just squeezes differentially due to varying elastic properties of the intestinal wall.
– theforestecologist
Nov 20 at 21:41
|
show 2 more comments
up vote
23
down vote
up vote
23
down vote
I'm almost certain that your question is based on the press that Patricia J Yang's research is receiving (e.g., here and here).
Yang and her co-authors examined the structure and mechanics of some dead wombats to investigate this question further. They found that varying degrees of pressure in the latter portion of the wombat's intestines (in conjunction with a dehydrating of the fecal matter) led to the characteristic cube shape:
From their abstract:
In the final 8 percent of the intestine, feces changed from a liquid-like state into a solid state composed of separated cubes of length 2 cm. This shape change was due to the azimuthally varying elastic properties of the intestinal wall. By emptying the intestine and inflating it with a long balloon, we found that the local strain varies from 20 percent at the cube's corners to 75 percent at its edges. Thus, the intestine stretches preferentially at the walls to facilitate cube formation.
Why do this?
There seems to be two major reasons:
- Mark territory
- Attract mates
For example, see Wells 19891:
The rubbing of posts, logs and overhanging branches with their backs and rumps and deposition of faeces along trails may be a means of olfactory communication used in the maintenance of territories
One hypothesis is that by being square, the droppings don't roll as easily and therefore stay in the place that the wombat intended to mark.
I've also seen hypotheses about wombats stacking their square feces as some sort of signaling, but I couldn't find any reputable literature sources that make this suggestion.
1: Wells, R.T., 1989. Vombatidae. Fauna of Australia, 1, pp.755-768.
I'm almost certain that your question is based on the press that Patricia J Yang's research is receiving (e.g., here and here).
Yang and her co-authors examined the structure and mechanics of some dead wombats to investigate this question further. They found that varying degrees of pressure in the latter portion of the wombat's intestines (in conjunction with a dehydrating of the fecal matter) led to the characteristic cube shape:
From their abstract:
In the final 8 percent of the intestine, feces changed from a liquid-like state into a solid state composed of separated cubes of length 2 cm. This shape change was due to the azimuthally varying elastic properties of the intestinal wall. By emptying the intestine and inflating it with a long balloon, we found that the local strain varies from 20 percent at the cube's corners to 75 percent at its edges. Thus, the intestine stretches preferentially at the walls to facilitate cube formation.
Why do this?
There seems to be two major reasons:
- Mark territory
- Attract mates
For example, see Wells 19891:
The rubbing of posts, logs and overhanging branches with their backs and rumps and deposition of faeces along trails may be a means of olfactory communication used in the maintenance of territories
One hypothesis is that by being square, the droppings don't roll as easily and therefore stay in the place that the wombat intended to mark.
I've also seen hypotheses about wombats stacking their square feces as some sort of signaling, but I couldn't find any reputable literature sources that make this suggestion.
1: Wells, R.T., 1989. Vombatidae. Fauna of Australia, 1, pp.755-768.
edited Nov 20 at 22:06
answered Nov 19 at 22:43
theforestecologist
15.3k670122
15.3k670122
1
The "Why do this?" part doesn't really explain why. Plenty of other creatures mark territory and attract mates, and they don't have square poops. Similarly the Wells quote seems unrelated.
– Parrotmaster
Nov 20 at 14:51
5
@Parrotmaster: As nature continually proves, multiple solutions to the same problem exist. Plenty of creatures are land-based animals but that doesn't prove that birds shouldn't have evolved to have wings. Recognizability of feces may not have been the reason for its inception (random mutations tend to be the reason for the inception of a trait), but the subsequent benefit of recognizability of the uniquely shaped droppings may explain why the trait persisted.
– Flater
Nov 20 at 15:09
1
@Parrotmaster take a look at Wells's paper for number of citations regarding the ethology and social-ecology of wombats
– theforestecologist
Nov 20 at 15:30
1
probably means there are 4 muscles around the intestine that form a square.
– gunfulker
Nov 20 at 20:37
1
@GraphTheory, no. The intestine supposedly just squeezes differentially due to varying elastic properties of the intestinal wall.
– theforestecologist
Nov 20 at 21:41
|
show 2 more comments
1
The "Why do this?" part doesn't really explain why. Plenty of other creatures mark territory and attract mates, and they don't have square poops. Similarly the Wells quote seems unrelated.
– Parrotmaster
Nov 20 at 14:51
5
@Parrotmaster: As nature continually proves, multiple solutions to the same problem exist. Plenty of creatures are land-based animals but that doesn't prove that birds shouldn't have evolved to have wings. Recognizability of feces may not have been the reason for its inception (random mutations tend to be the reason for the inception of a trait), but the subsequent benefit of recognizability of the uniquely shaped droppings may explain why the trait persisted.
– Flater
Nov 20 at 15:09
1
@Parrotmaster take a look at Wells's paper for number of citations regarding the ethology and social-ecology of wombats
– theforestecologist
Nov 20 at 15:30
1
probably means there are 4 muscles around the intestine that form a square.
– gunfulker
Nov 20 at 20:37
1
@GraphTheory, no. The intestine supposedly just squeezes differentially due to varying elastic properties of the intestinal wall.
– theforestecologist
Nov 20 at 21:41
1
1
The "Why do this?" part doesn't really explain why. Plenty of other creatures mark territory and attract mates, and they don't have square poops. Similarly the Wells quote seems unrelated.
– Parrotmaster
Nov 20 at 14:51
The "Why do this?" part doesn't really explain why. Plenty of other creatures mark territory and attract mates, and they don't have square poops. Similarly the Wells quote seems unrelated.
– Parrotmaster
Nov 20 at 14:51
5
5
@Parrotmaster: As nature continually proves, multiple solutions to the same problem exist. Plenty of creatures are land-based animals but that doesn't prove that birds shouldn't have evolved to have wings. Recognizability of feces may not have been the reason for its inception (random mutations tend to be the reason for the inception of a trait), but the subsequent benefit of recognizability of the uniquely shaped droppings may explain why the trait persisted.
– Flater
Nov 20 at 15:09
@Parrotmaster: As nature continually proves, multiple solutions to the same problem exist. Plenty of creatures are land-based animals but that doesn't prove that birds shouldn't have evolved to have wings. Recognizability of feces may not have been the reason for its inception (random mutations tend to be the reason for the inception of a trait), but the subsequent benefit of recognizability of the uniquely shaped droppings may explain why the trait persisted.
– Flater
Nov 20 at 15:09
1
1
@Parrotmaster take a look at Wells's paper for number of citations regarding the ethology and social-ecology of wombats
– theforestecologist
Nov 20 at 15:30
@Parrotmaster take a look at Wells's paper for number of citations regarding the ethology and social-ecology of wombats
– theforestecologist
Nov 20 at 15:30
1
1
probably means there are 4 muscles around the intestine that form a square.
– gunfulker
Nov 20 at 20:37
probably means there are 4 muscles around the intestine that form a square.
– gunfulker
Nov 20 at 20:37
1
1
@GraphTheory, no. The intestine supposedly just squeezes differentially due to varying elastic properties of the intestinal wall.
– theforestecologist
Nov 20 at 21:41
@GraphTheory, no. The intestine supposedly just squeezes differentially due to varying elastic properties of the intestinal wall.
– theforestecologist
Nov 20 at 21:41
|
show 2 more comments
up vote
9
down vote
On a more serious note than my comment, and as a supplement to theforestecologist's answer, it's worth pointing out that a cube with rounded corners and edges has larger surface area to volume ratio than a spherical dropping, making it more efficient for the reabsorbtion of moisture, which would be an evolutionary advantage in a place where water is in short supply (as it is in large parts of Australia).
Additionally, in respect of the claim made here that droppings are used for marking, it may be advantageous to have a dropping that doesn't roll, if it's important some subsequent visitor can identify the precise spot the droppings were dropped, especially if one inhabits sloped terrain (which a wombat does - mountainous areas of Australia) where a round dropping might roll and mark an ambiguous spot.
Some of the information contained in this post requires additional references. Please edit to add citations to reliable sources that support the assertions made here. Unsourced material may be disputed or deleted.
2
Why would feces reabsorbing moisture be an advantage? Do wombats eat their droppings?
– Paul
Nov 20 at 12:44
7
@Paul I guess he meant colon absorbing moisture from feces to conserve water.
– user31389
Nov 20 at 13:00
9
@Paul a standard function of the colon in all animals is to reabsorb nutrients and fluid from doo doo before it's expelled.
– Robert Frost
Nov 20 at 13:29
add a comment |
up vote
9
down vote
On a more serious note than my comment, and as a supplement to theforestecologist's answer, it's worth pointing out that a cube with rounded corners and edges has larger surface area to volume ratio than a spherical dropping, making it more efficient for the reabsorbtion of moisture, which would be an evolutionary advantage in a place where water is in short supply (as it is in large parts of Australia).
Additionally, in respect of the claim made here that droppings are used for marking, it may be advantageous to have a dropping that doesn't roll, if it's important some subsequent visitor can identify the precise spot the droppings were dropped, especially if one inhabits sloped terrain (which a wombat does - mountainous areas of Australia) where a round dropping might roll and mark an ambiguous spot.
Some of the information contained in this post requires additional references. Please edit to add citations to reliable sources that support the assertions made here. Unsourced material may be disputed or deleted.
2
Why would feces reabsorbing moisture be an advantage? Do wombats eat their droppings?
– Paul
Nov 20 at 12:44
7
@Paul I guess he meant colon absorbing moisture from feces to conserve water.
– user31389
Nov 20 at 13:00
9
@Paul a standard function of the colon in all animals is to reabsorb nutrients and fluid from doo doo before it's expelled.
– Robert Frost
Nov 20 at 13:29
add a comment |
up vote
9
down vote
up vote
9
down vote
On a more serious note than my comment, and as a supplement to theforestecologist's answer, it's worth pointing out that a cube with rounded corners and edges has larger surface area to volume ratio than a spherical dropping, making it more efficient for the reabsorbtion of moisture, which would be an evolutionary advantage in a place where water is in short supply (as it is in large parts of Australia).
Additionally, in respect of the claim made here that droppings are used for marking, it may be advantageous to have a dropping that doesn't roll, if it's important some subsequent visitor can identify the precise spot the droppings were dropped, especially if one inhabits sloped terrain (which a wombat does - mountainous areas of Australia) where a round dropping might roll and mark an ambiguous spot.
On a more serious note than my comment, and as a supplement to theforestecologist's answer, it's worth pointing out that a cube with rounded corners and edges has larger surface area to volume ratio than a spherical dropping, making it more efficient for the reabsorbtion of moisture, which would be an evolutionary advantage in a place where water is in short supply (as it is in large parts of Australia).
Additionally, in respect of the claim made here that droppings are used for marking, it may be advantageous to have a dropping that doesn't roll, if it's important some subsequent visitor can identify the precise spot the droppings were dropped, especially if one inhabits sloped terrain (which a wombat does - mountainous areas of Australia) where a round dropping might roll and mark an ambiguous spot.
edited Nov 21 at 9:52
answered Nov 20 at 9:30
Robert Frost
1994
1994
Some of the information contained in this post requires additional references. Please edit to add citations to reliable sources that support the assertions made here. Unsourced material may be disputed or deleted.
Some of the information contained in this post requires additional references. Please edit to add citations to reliable sources that support the assertions made here. Unsourced material may be disputed or deleted.
2
Why would feces reabsorbing moisture be an advantage? Do wombats eat their droppings?
– Paul
Nov 20 at 12:44
7
@Paul I guess he meant colon absorbing moisture from feces to conserve water.
– user31389
Nov 20 at 13:00
9
@Paul a standard function of the colon in all animals is to reabsorb nutrients and fluid from doo doo before it's expelled.
– Robert Frost
Nov 20 at 13:29
add a comment |
2
Why would feces reabsorbing moisture be an advantage? Do wombats eat their droppings?
– Paul
Nov 20 at 12:44
7
@Paul I guess he meant colon absorbing moisture from feces to conserve water.
– user31389
Nov 20 at 13:00
9
@Paul a standard function of the colon in all animals is to reabsorb nutrients and fluid from doo doo before it's expelled.
– Robert Frost
Nov 20 at 13:29
2
2
Why would feces reabsorbing moisture be an advantage? Do wombats eat their droppings?
– Paul
Nov 20 at 12:44
Why would feces reabsorbing moisture be an advantage? Do wombats eat their droppings?
– Paul
Nov 20 at 12:44
7
7
@Paul I guess he meant colon absorbing moisture from feces to conserve water.
– user31389
Nov 20 at 13:00
@Paul I guess he meant colon absorbing moisture from feces to conserve water.
– user31389
Nov 20 at 13:00
9
9
@Paul a standard function of the colon in all animals is to reabsorb nutrients and fluid from doo doo before it's expelled.
– Robert Frost
Nov 20 at 13:29
@Paul a standard function of the colon in all animals is to reabsorb nutrients and fluid from doo doo before it's expelled.
– Robert Frost
Nov 20 at 13:29
add a comment |
Thanks for contributing an answer to Biology Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
Use MathJax to format equations. MathJax reference.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Some of your past answers have not been well-received, and you're in danger of being blocked from answering.
Please pay close attention to the following guidance:
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fbiology.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f79162%2fwhy-is-wombat-excreta-shaped-like-cubes%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown